! Facebook Censorship and Community Regulation, A possible solution! - Criticism is always easy while coming up with a solution is hard! SO I HAVE TRIED TO FIND A SOLUTION!
.
SO I HAVE TRIED TO FIND A SOLUTION!
.
An Alternative Solution!
MK 1
.
INTRODUCTION!
.
I hate and loath Facebook nonsensical and inconsistent community guidelines policy.
While the policy itself is all written out, fairly clearly
Its real day to day enforcement is a ridiculous and weird joke.
.
I have had a piece of art banned, of a person simply crying, while the piece of art both above and below (also by me) that picture showing nudity and gore and violence is never questioned.
.
However,
Any man and their dog can bitch and moan about a problem!
Criticism is always easy peasy shitty squeezy
While coming up with a solution is hard!
SO I HAVE TRIED TO FIND A SOLUTION!
.
.
Dear Mickey Boy Zuckerberg
If you can get past this disrespectful familiarity then I might have a solution for you.
(Don’t take it too personally, I believe in both God and the Devil and have decided to tell them both to “fuck off”.)
(If I am far too narcissistic, delusionary arrogant to bow to them, what chance does any earthly king, queen, government or mere CEO possibly have??!!)
(But I digress, this is not about me…)
Of course, the chance of you or anyone of influence in Facebook actually ever reading any of this is less likely than me winning a lottery jackpot when I have never brought a ticket!
BUT AT LEAST I TRIED!
.
.
For The Record:
For what very little it is worth.
I do strongly believe that governments should keep their slimy hands both off Facebook and off the internet in general.
It is probably the ONLY thing we might agree on!
.
.
Mike’s Possible Question:
“It is MY bloody company!”
“Why the hell should I not be allowed to decide what the hell I want goes on my owned product?”
.
My Answer:
Just like the Laws of Physics change close to a singularity.
The rules have to change for something as large as Facebook.
This is not like a mere newspaper or tv network.
This is not like an editor deciding what can and can not go on their media.
The size scope and influence of ALL social media, and Facebook in particular is unprecedented and the same normal rules of simply “Who owns what” is simply no longer adequate.
.
.
The Solution.
Instead of ANY “independent” review board or reviewers.
(Which cost money!)
LET THE WORLD DECIDE!
.
Although in mechanics this is going to seem overly complex.
Please bear in mind that from a user UI perspective the whole system is a simple as a Vote Up vs a Vote Down click!
.
For this example, we will use that random statement by a “Mr Random Person” saying
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
.
Note: The film was actually out in 1986! But the incorrect fact is part of the example!
.
.
Stage One
The Ban Nomination!
.
By a simple vote of 10 votes down by anyone seeing the statement.
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
By
Mr Random Person
.
Gets the post nominated for a ban.
Upon the tenth vote down, a 24 clock hour starts.
A clock that everyone can see!
.
.
Stage Two
The Post Ban Process.
.
As soon as the tenth downvote from the stage one nomination happens,
Upon the tenth vote down, a 24 clock hour starts.
A clock that everyone can see!
(24 hours to allow supporters and detractors alike to shout for and rally for some support!)
.
Everyone must see the clock countdown, on each “nominated for a ban” post!
.
Now the whole world can decide if that post,
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
By
Mr Random Person
Should or should not be banned!
.
Each vote down counts as one point!
BUT
Each vote to keep counts as two points!
These upvote points are deducted from ANY and ALL downvotes for that post!
(ANY decision for censorship must be overwhelming!)
If the number of overall votes to ban, when the clock hits zero, is 100 or more.
Then that post is banned and automatically deleted!
.
.
Stage 3
The Ban of an individual
.
Anyone who has any ban nomination clock running,
On ANY posts of theirs, COMBINED!
Has a chance of having their account restricted.
.
IF, while a “Nomination Clock “ is running, that person gets 100 downvotes points, on all current active posts combined!
(Remembering that all single upvotes count as two points, against anyone point downvote!)
Then that person risks their own individual, account being banned!
.
The beauty of this is its effectiveness against spammers!
The More you spam the more like you will be to get enough downvotes for an account restriction!
REMEMBER!
The votes are counted from ALL posts, while ANY post clock is running, NOT just a single post!
.
The level of account restriction will then be determined by the number of total Down Vote points for ALL posts (while any clock was running) collected in ANY 48 hours, period!
(48 hours to allow for every time zone population to have vote click twice over!)
.
1000 Total Down Votes
24-hour restriction.
.
10,000 total Down Votes
7-day restriction.
.
100,000 total Down Votes
30-day restriction.
.
1000,000 total Down Votes
LIFETIME BAN AND ACCOUNT DELETION!
(On million for such an action is a good round number and reminds me a bit of the people's voice the famous Million Man March!)
.
BUT AGAIN!
REMEMBER!
Each vote to keep counts as two points!
These upvote points are deducted from ANY and ALL downvotes for that person!
(ANY decision for censorship must be overwhelming!)
.
.
PROPORTIONAL ENFORCEMENT RESPONSE!
.
NOTE:
The number of transgressions has no bearing at all on any restrictions.
Each case is only ever based on any single vote by vote response!
.
So in theory a person can say risqué things often and get an unlimited number of single-day bans, each one a result of different single transgressions.
.
Facebook Censorship and Community Regulation,
!
A possible solution!
!
- Criticism is always easy while coming up with a solution is hard!
!
SO I HAVE TRIED TO FIND A SOLUTION!
!
https://www.lombot.co.uk/p/facebook-censorship-and-community.html?zx=24b29acfbc8eccec
!
Facebook Censorship and Community Regulation
.
Criticism is always easy while coming up with a solution is hard!
.SO I HAVE TRIED TO FIND A SOLUTION!
.
An Alternative Solution!
MK 1
.
INTRODUCTION!
.
“Don’t give me problems”
“Give me solutions”
. I hate and loath Facebook nonsensical and inconsistent community guidelines policy.
While the policy itself is all written out, fairly clearly
Its real day to day enforcement is a ridiculous and weird joke.
.
I have had a piece of art banned, of a person simply crying, while the piece of art both above and below (also by me) that picture showing nudity and gore and violence is never questioned.
.
However,
Any man and their dog can bitch and moan about a problem!
Criticism is always easy peasy shitty squeezy
While coming up with a solution is hard!
SO I HAVE TRIED TO FIND A SOLUTION!
.
.
Dear Mickey Boy Zuckerberg
If you can get past this disrespectful familiarity then I might have a solution for you.
(Don’t take it too personally, I believe in both God and the Devil and have decided to tell them both to “fuck off”.)
(If I am far too narcissistic, delusionary arrogant to bow to them, what chance does any earthly king, queen, government or mere CEO possibly have??!!)
(But I digress, this is not about me…)
Of course, the chance of you or anyone of influence in Facebook actually ever reading any of this is less likely than me winning a lottery jackpot when I have never brought a ticket!
BUT AT LEAST I TRIED!
.
.
For The Record:
For what very little it is worth.
I do strongly believe that governments should keep their slimy hands both off Facebook and off the internet in general.
It is probably the ONLY thing we might agree on!
.
.
Mike’s Possible Question:
“It is MY bloody company!”
“Why the hell should I not be allowed to decide what the hell I want goes on my owned product?”
.
My Answer:
Just like the Laws of Physics change close to a singularity.
The rules have to change for something as large as Facebook.
This is not like a mere newspaper or tv network.
This is not like an editor deciding what can and can not go on their media.
The size scope and influence of ALL social media, and Facebook in particular is unprecedented and the same normal rules of simply “Who owns what” is simply no longer adequate.
.
.
The Solution.
Instead of ANY “independent” review board or reviewers.
(Which cost money!)
LET THE WORLD DECIDE!
.
Although in mechanics this is going to seem overly complex.
Please bear in mind that from a user UI perspective the whole system is a simple as a Vote Up vs a Vote Down click!
.
For this example, we will use that random statement by a “Mr Random Person” saying
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
.
Note: The film was actually out in 1986! But the incorrect fact is part of the example!
.
.
Stage One
The Ban Nomination!
.
By a simple vote of 10 votes down by anyone seeing the statement.
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
By
Mr Random Person
.
Gets the post nominated for a ban.
Upon the tenth vote down, a 24 clock hour starts.
A clock that everyone can see!
.
.
Stage Two
The Post Ban Process.
.
As soon as the tenth downvote from the stage one nomination happens,
Upon the tenth vote down, a 24 clock hour starts.
A clock that everyone can see!
(24 hours to allow supporters and detractors alike to shout for and rally for some support!)
.
Everyone must see the clock countdown, on each “nominated for a ban” post!
.
Now the whole world can decide if that post,
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
By
Mr Random Person
Should or should not be banned!
.
Each vote down counts as one point!
BUT
Each vote to keep counts as two points!
These upvote points are deducted from ANY and ALL downvotes for that post!
(ANY decision for censorship must be overwhelming!)
If the number of overall votes to ban, when the clock hits zero, is 100 or more.
Then that post is banned and automatically deleted!
.
.
Stage 3
The Ban of an individual
.
Anyone who has any ban nomination clock running,
On ANY posts of theirs, COMBINED!
Has a chance of having their account restricted.
.
IF, while a “Nomination Clock “ is running, that person gets 100 downvotes points, on all current active posts combined!
(Remembering that all single upvotes count as two points, against anyone point downvote!)
Then that person risks their own individual, account being banned!
.
The beauty of this is its effectiveness against spammers!
The More you spam the more like you will be to get enough downvotes for an account restriction!
REMEMBER!
The votes are counted from ALL posts, while ANY post clock is running, NOT just a single post!
.
The level of account restriction will then be determined by the number of total Down Vote points for ALL posts (while any clock was running) collected in ANY 48 hours, period!
(48 hours to allow for every time zone population to have vote click twice over!)
.
1000 Total Down Votes
24-hour restriction.
.
10,000 total Down Votes
7-day restriction.
.
100,000 total Down Votes
30-day restriction.
.
1000,000 total Down Votes
LIFETIME BAN AND ACCOUNT DELETION!
(On million for such an action is a good round number and reminds me a bit of the people's voice the famous Million Man March!)
.
BUT AGAIN!
REMEMBER!
Each vote to keep counts as two points!
These upvote points are deducted from ANY and ALL downvotes for that person!
(ANY decision for censorship must be overwhelming!)
.
.
PROPORTIONAL ENFORCEMENT RESPONSE!
.
NOTE:
The number of transgressions has no bearing at all on any restrictions.
Each case is only ever based on any single vote by vote response!
.
So in theory a person can say risqué things often and get an unlimited number of single-day bans, each one a result of different single transgressions.
.
While one single statement of pure bile of evil could mean a lifetime ban from a single horrid statement! Even if that statement is a very first-time offence!
.
To me, that sounds far more like, reasonable proportional judgement to be censored (or not) as decided by the whole world!
.
.
THE IMPORTANT BIT!
.
.
To me, that sounds far more like, reasonable proportional judgement to be censored (or not) as decided by the whole world!
.
.
THE IMPORTANT BIT!
.
Is that no matter how much advertising revenue they produce.
No matter how small a following some granny has for her cat pictures.
No matter how much political power they have.
No matter how extreme the views of someone wearing a tinfoil hat in their mums' basement!
That everyone account gets treated equally!
Whether King Or lowly peasant!
One million downvotes points after any deducted upvotes points! STILL MEANS AN ACCOUNT DELETION AND BAN!
NO EXCEPTIONS!
.
.
IMPORTANT BIT TWO!
We need complete transparency.
No secret votes!
Everyone should be able to see what any other person has upvoted or downvoted on!
And these facts must be openly shown on that person's profile!
IF you have the gall to either try to censor a post OR support a horrendous viewpoint, then you should bear the responsibility of owning and publicly standing by your decision!
If you as to shy too or cowardly to openly stand by or attempt to ban the statement.
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
By
Mr Random Person
Then you should NOT vote in the first place!
Such a decision should be taken very seriously!
N0T taken frivolously and in the safely of the dark!
.
All numbers on any decision should be publicly displayed for all to see.
Include graphs of clock rundowns vs the number of votes!
.
Any form of judgement or justice system MUST be completely transparent, in order to work!
.
.
Downside’s
.
Foriegn mass properganda posters, misinformation, extemeist, ect, OH MY!
.
This is why any upvotes are worth double and taken off any collection of downvotes!
To make that sort of thing and those sort of negative influences harder to gain any ground!
BUT NO SYSTEM IS PERFECT!
If a single human shadow is within a lightyear of any system, then it will have fundamental flaws!
Because ALL us humans, without exception, are ALL intently, deep down shit!
.
.
It could, so easily, all go horribly wrong!
.
I hate Nazis and bigotry
I hate homophobia being justified by religion and then blasphemously called “Holy”
I hate the anti-vaxers, who have cost so many lives and never get to see who they have killed to ever feel accountable!
I hate Trump and the disgusting ICE policy!
BUT
I as an individual should not have the power to say what OR who should OR should Not be censored!
No single individual should have that amount of power!
AND NEITHER SHOULD ANY SINGLE CORPORATION OR COMPANY!
If the world creates its own digital hell (or utopia) then let it!
LET THE WORLD DECIDE!
.
.
Upsides!
.
1)
Once in place, this system will be much cheaper than paying various reviewers or panels!
.
2)
Mass world consensus will be far more impartial than the on-spot decision of you or anyone working for you, or even me!
.
3)
The dynamic battles among factions to try and get each other life banned and take some sort of control.
This will thin the heard and let all the most extremist views nuke each other to lifetime ban Facebook oblivion.
Leaving Facebook a far more socially stable and (once the smoke clears) more pleasant place for all.
.
4)
Any vote battle will be tense dramatic and easily worth more generated hits, better add space revenue as people get heavily invested in an outcome,
So, more heaps of money!
.
5)
You personally and Facebook as a whole can wash their hands of any consequence!
You let the world make its own heaven or hell!
Not your fault!
Not your problem!
.
.
WHAT A PILE OF CRAP??!!
.
No matter how small a following some granny has for her cat pictures.
No matter how much political power they have.
No matter how extreme the views of someone wearing a tinfoil hat in their mums' basement!
That everyone account gets treated equally!
Whether King Or lowly peasant!
One million downvotes points after any deducted upvotes points! STILL MEANS AN ACCOUNT DELETION AND BAN!
NO EXCEPTIONS!
.
.
IMPORTANT BIT TWO!
We need complete transparency.
No secret votes!
Everyone should be able to see what any other person has upvoted or downvoted on!
And these facts must be openly shown on that person's profile!
IF you have the gall to either try to censor a post OR support a horrendous viewpoint, then you should bear the responsibility of owning and publicly standing by your decision!
If you as to shy too or cowardly to openly stand by or attempt to ban the statement.
“The 1987 film Howard the Duck is the worst film ever!”
By
Mr Random Person
Then you should NOT vote in the first place!
Such a decision should be taken very seriously!
N0T taken frivolously and in the safely of the dark!
.
All numbers on any decision should be publicly displayed for all to see.
Include graphs of clock rundowns vs the number of votes!
.
Any form of judgement or justice system MUST be completely transparent, in order to work!
.
.
Downside’s
.
Foriegn mass properganda posters, misinformation, extemeist, ect, OH MY!
.
This is why any upvotes are worth double and taken off any collection of downvotes!
To make that sort of thing and those sort of negative influences harder to gain any ground!
BUT NO SYSTEM IS PERFECT!
If a single human shadow is within a lightyear of any system, then it will have fundamental flaws!
Because ALL us humans, without exception, are ALL intently, deep down shit!
.
.
It could, so easily, all go horribly wrong!
.
I hate Nazis and bigotry
I hate homophobia being justified by religion and then blasphemously called “Holy”
I hate the anti-vaxers, who have cost so many lives and never get to see who they have killed to ever feel accountable!
I hate Trump and the disgusting ICE policy!
BUT
I as an individual should not have the power to say what OR who should OR should Not be censored!
No single individual should have that amount of power!
AND NEITHER SHOULD ANY SINGLE CORPORATION OR COMPANY!
If the world creates its own digital hell (or utopia) then let it!
LET THE WORLD DECIDE!
.
.
Upsides!
.
1)
Once in place, this system will be much cheaper than paying various reviewers or panels!
.
2)
Mass world consensus will be far more impartial than the on-spot decision of you or anyone working for you, or even me!
.
3)
The dynamic battles among factions to try and get each other life banned and take some sort of control.
This will thin the heard and let all the most extremist views nuke each other to lifetime ban Facebook oblivion.
Leaving Facebook a far more socially stable and (once the smoke clears) more pleasant place for all.
.
4)
Any vote battle will be tense dramatic and easily worth more generated hits, better add space revenue as people get heavily invested in an outcome,
So, more heaps of money!
.
5)
You personally and Facebook as a whole can wash their hands of any consequence!
You let the world make its own heaven or hell!
Not your fault!
Not your problem!
.
.
WHAT A PILE OF CRAP??!!
.
Maybe all of this is total crap?
Maybe there are just shadows of one or two ideas worth pondering in this lot of text?
And as stated before earlier… Of course, the chance of you or anyone of influence in Facebook actually ever reading any of this is less likely than me winning a lottery jackpot when I have never brought a ticket!
BUT at least I tried to offer a solution not just bitch and moan about the problem!
.
.
PUT IT THIS WAY! Mikey!
.
Doing this (or anything else) is far better than letting congress or any other single country, break up Facebook and have undue influence on all social media as a whole.
Because if you do nothing at all, to change how things are
Maybe there are just shadows of one or two ideas worth pondering in this lot of text?
And as stated before earlier… Of course, the chance of you or anyone of influence in Facebook actually ever reading any of this is less likely than me winning a lottery jackpot when I have never brought a ticket!
BUT at least I tried to offer a solution not just bitch and moan about the problem!
.
.
PUT IT THIS WAY! Mikey!
.
Doing this (or anything else) is far better than letting congress or any other single country, break up Facebook and have undue influence on all social media as a whole.
Because if you do nothing at all, to change how things are
(Not just campaigning against such measures but actively change Facebooks censorship structure itself!)
THEN THAT IS EXACTLY WHAT WILL HAPPEN!
.!
!
!
!
!
Oi!
Trump Tards!
I AM NOT ONE OF YOU!
My beef with Facebook is ONLY an anti-censorship / anti-Facebook one ONLY!
NOT an antisemitic ONE!
I DISLIKE MIKE THE MAN ONLY!
I do NOT Support ANY pro-nazi crap!
PS
BLM
There is NO "Jewish conspiracy" you stupid QAnon, red cap made out of tin foil into a hat, wearing nuts!!
Long live ANTIFA!
!
.
!Oi!
Trump Tards!
I AM NOT ONE OF YOU!
My beef with Facebook is ONLY an anti-censorship / anti-Facebook one ONLY!
NOT an antisemitic ONE!
I DISLIKE MIKE THE MAN ONLY!
I do NOT Support ANY pro-nazi crap!
PS
BLM
There is NO "Jewish conspiracy" you stupid QAnon, red cap made out of tin foil into a hat, wearing nuts!!
Long live ANTIFA!
!
.
Facebook Censorship and Community Regulation,
!
A possible solution!
!
- Criticism is always easy while coming up with a solution is hard!
!
SO I HAVE TRIED TO FIND A SOLUTION!
!
https://www.lombot.co.uk/p/facebook-censorship-and-community.html?zx=24b29acfbc8eccec
!
Posts
Comments
Post a Comment